Build Real Opportunities for Success

Students develop mathematical confidence through repeated experiences where their effort leads to meaningful progress.

When students consistently encounter confusion, barriers, embarrassment, or failure, they may begin to disconnect from mathematics entirely. Over time, students stop viewing struggles as temporary and begin viewing them as evidence that they simply are not “math people.”

This shift matters because mathematical identity influences:

• participation,

• persistence,

• confidence,

• willingness to take risks,

• and future opportunities.

Students are more likely to engage deeply with mathematics when they experience classrooms where they feel capable, supported, and valued as thinkers.

Jump to a Section

Students remember the messages classrooms send about who belongs in mathematics.

Some students repeatedly hear:

• “You need to try harder.”

• “You should already know this.”

• “You’re behind.”

• “You’re too slow.”

• “Pay attention.”

Even when these statements are not spoken directly, students may internalize them through classroom structures that reward only:

• speed,

• accuracy,

• independence,

• or immediate understanding.

Over time, repeated struggles can become part of a student’s identity.

Students may begin thinking:

“I’m just bad at math.”

rather than:

“I’m struggling with this concept right now.”

Students need opportunities to experience success that are connected to meaningful mathematical thinking, not only answer-getting.

Success can look like:

• explaining reasoning clearly,

• noticing a pattern,

• asking a thoughtful question,

• revising an idea,

• persisting through a challenge,

• making a useful connection,

• or contributing to a group discussion.

When classrooms recognize only correct answers completed quickly, many students’ strengths remain invisible.

Students are more likely to persist when they believe their thinking has value, even when it is unfinished or still developing.

A student may understand mathematics while still struggling with:

• reading demands,

• executive functioning,

• communication,

• organization,

• sensory overload,

• or unclear expectations.

When these barriers repeatedly interfere with performance, students may never experience opportunities to demonstrate what they actually know.

This is especially important because students often compare themselves to peers who appear to complete tasks more easily or more quickly.

Without meaningful opportunities for success, students may begin avoiding participation entirely as a way to protect themselves from frustration or embarrassment.

Students are more willing to take intellectual risks when mistakes are treated as part of learning rather than evidence of failure.

In some classrooms, students become highly focused on avoiding errors because mistakes feel public, stressful, or embarrassing.

This can lead students to:

• stay silent,

• avoid challenging tasks,

• rely heavily on memorization,

• or disengage from mathematics altogether.

Classrooms that normalize revision, discussion, and unfinished thinking help students view mathematics as something they can grow within rather than something they either “have” or “don’t have.”

Students need opportunities to participate in ways that feel accessible and meaningful.

Not all students feel comfortable:

• speaking immediately,

• sharing publicly,

• working under time pressure,

• or participating in the same ways as their peers.

Students are more likely to engage when classrooms provide:

• processing time,

• flexible participation structures,

• collaborative opportunities,

• clear expectations,

• and supportive feedback.

Students should not have to overcome unnecessary barriers before they are able to contribute.

Teachers can help build meaningful opportunities for success by:

• valuing reasoning and effort, not only speed,

• recognizing growth and revision,

• providing supportive feedback,

• creating multiple ways for students to participate,

• reducing unnecessary barriers,

• allowing productive struggle without shame,

• and intentionally noticing students’ strengths.

Small moments matter.

A student who feels seen as capable is more likely to continue engaging with mathematics, even when learning becomes difficult.

Students remember classrooms where they felt successful not because the mathematics was easy, but because they were trusted as thinkers while they were still learning.